MLK said: "Injustice Anywhere is a Threat to Justice Everywhere"

End Corruption in the Courts!

Court employee, judge or citizen - Report Corruption in any Court Today !! As of June 15, 2016, we've received over 142,500 tips...KEEP THEM COMING !! Email:

Monday, December 14, 2009

Big Ex-Clients Start Suing Big Law Firms

Ex-Client Sues Paul Hastings for $55 Million in Soured Loan
The New York Law Journal by Nate Raymond - December 14, 2009

A financing unit of Cerberus Capital Management L.P. has sued Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker, claiming the law firm gave it bad advice in connection with a loan the private equity firm made last year to a company looking to bring retailer Steve & Barry's out of bankruptcy. Ableco Finance LLC, a unit of Cerberus with more than $6 billion under management, filed an amended complaint Friday in Manhattan Supreme Court against its former lawyers seeking more than $55 million it said it lost because of the $125 million loan. Ableco claims it would never have made the loan last year if the Paul Hastings team had advised it that the buyer would not have rights to all of Steve & Barry's inventory, which Ableco understood would back the loan. "No competent, diligent finance lawyer would have put his client in such a vulnerable position," Ableco's complaint reads in part. A spokesman for Paul Hastings, which is represented by Paul Spagnoletti at Davis Polk & Wardwell, said the firm looked forward to defending itself in court. "Paul Hastings adheres to the highest standards of professionalism and integrity in the representation of its clients, and its representation of Ableco in this matter was no exception," the spokesman said. "It's unfortunate that Ableco has chosen to sue its longtime legal adviser to recoup business losses caused by the economic downturn." Both a spokeswoman for Cerberus and Ableco's lawyer, Stuart Shapiro at Shapiro Forman Allen & Sava, declined to comment. The case, Ableco Finance LLC v. Hilson, 650618/2009, before Acting Supreme Court Justice Shirley Kornreich (See Profile), was first filed in October.

Ableco's decision to sue Paul Hastings marked the end of what the company said in court papers was a 14-year relationship with John F. Hilson, a Los Angeles-based corporate partner at Paul Hastings. Mr. Hilson had represented Ableco in "hundreds" of transactions. In August 2008, Ableco retained Mr. Hilson and Mario Ippolito, a Paul Hastings partner in New York, to represent it in financing a buyer looking to purchase assets out of the Steve & Barry's bankruptcy. Steve & Barry's had filed for Chapter 11 in the Southern District Bankruptcy Court in July 2008. Bay Harbour Management, a private equity firm specializing in buying distressed companies, sought to purchase the retailer's assets out of bankruptcy and turned to Ableco to help finance the deal with a $125 million loan. Bay Harbour set up a portfolio company for the transaction called BH S&B Holdings. It was a difficult time to make a loan, given "an economy that was suffering major disruptions in the housing and credit markets," Ableco said in its complaint. To ensure it got paid back in full, Ableco said it told Paul Hastings lawyers to require a first priority lien on Steve & Barry's entire inventory, which Ableco estimated to be worth $183.7 million. Language agreeing to a first priority lien made it into the commitment letter drafted by Paul Hastings, and Ableco agreed to make the loan.

But according to the complaint, Ableco had not been advised about an earlier agreement between Bay Harbour and Steve & Barry's that would have made a right to the entire inventory impossible. Bay Harbour's earlier agreement with Steve & Barry's left the retailer with control of more than 50 percent of its stores. While the estate had given Bay Harbour a lien on the assets at these stores, the estate kept priority rights to the inventory and sales proceeds that came ahead of that lien. As a result, Ableco claimed it was in fact impossible for it to receive its lien on a large portion of Steve & Barry's inventory. Ableco said Paul Hastings did not provide a copy of the earlier agreement between Bay Harbour and the retailer's estate, nor communicated its terms, before Ableco made the loan. With the economy worsening, the company created by Bay Harbour, BH S&B Holdings, began to struggle and it filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the Southern District in November 2008. It was not until the BH S&B bankruptcy filing that Ableco learned that Steve & Barry's estate claimed it owned the inventory in more than half the stores and Ableco did not have a first priority lien. An Ableco executive confronted Mr. Ippolito at Paul Hastings almost immediately. "I find it hard to imagine that you did not bring this matter to my attention pre closing," Paul Lusardi, a senior vice president of Cerberus Capital and at Ableco, said in a November 2008 e-mail. "I would never have recommended closing the deal if I knew we were not going to have a free and clear lien on all of the assets." The bankruptcy by the Bay Harbour affiliate also put at risk $28.5 million in loan repayments Ableco received in the 90 days before the Chapter 11 filing. As a result, Ableco said it entered into a "very costly" settlement. Paul Hastings, in a motion to dismiss filed in November, said Ableco is trying to blame its lawyers for decisions it made in a bad economy. "In bringing this lawsuit, [Ableco], a sophisticated lender, is trying to hold its attorneys liable for its own bad business decisions and any losses that may arise from them, not from any breach of duty by the attorneys," Paul Hastings said in the motion. Nate Raymond can be reached at


ex client of big law firm said...

Don't forget, it's the big firms that hold the hammer over judges (and their decisions). Payback or get clobbered.

Anonymous said...

and they give the most campaign contributions!
and anyone else who wants their financing at low rates!

Anonymous said...

Hell, from my point of view more of these large law firms should be sued. They think they can do whatever they want and no one can ever get to them. Sue them all

Anonymous said...

they do, they work cases so that other firms can not survive, so that other firms(lawyers) do as they say or else
so why haven't the FEDS infilitrated the Courts and Attorney Grievance Committees, to stop the RICO and allow rights to due process?

Anonymous said...

The FEDS told me in 2006, that they are too busy fighting the terrorists coming through Canada.. so I must ask...have you heard or seen any of them being arrested or detected from there.. and that is where the boys are hanging!
Tooo busy chasing the men they are ACTUALLY finding in the body and not the borders.... of the USA!

Anonymous said...

the economy has been weak for a few years now. Thought they would just say they did not do anything wrong. Amazing that lawyers can say whatever they want and not be held accountable for anything.
When they get to court they can not remember anything and they never said or did that.
As a non lawyer your word means nothing.

Anonymous said...

we need more lawsuits against lawyers. the more lawsuits it wil make them do thier job the correct way. you go to a doctor they are so affraid of being sued that they try tp tske every precaution. I feel sory for them. Yet lawyers do not care.

Anonymous said...

they just band together at the large law firms to conspire, keeps the criminals in one place teaching each other!

Anonymous said...

Nice dispatch and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you as your information.

Blog Archive

See Video of Senator John L. Sampson's 1st Hearing on Court 'Ethics' Corruption

The first hearing, held in Albany on June 8, 2009 hearing is on two videos:

               Video of 1st Hearing on Court 'Ethics' Corruption
               The June 8, 2009 hearing is on two videos:
               CLICK HERE TO SEE Part 1
               CLICK HERE TO SEE Part 2
Add to Technorati Favorites